[Verse 1]
I bet you're from out west somewhere
Hazel eyes and dark brown hair
And everything you wear fits you just right
I bet you drink martinis dry
And never let 'em see you cry
Oh, I bet you're more promiscuous than I

[Pre-Chorus]
I bet you're bold, I bet that's why you seem to occupy his mind
I bet you're smart, but do you know about me?

[Chorus]
Is it me? Is it you?
Tell me who, who's the other girl?
Who's the first? Who's the fool?
Who's the diamond? Who's the pearl?
Are you mad? Me too
And I wonder, in his world
Is it me? Is it you?
Who's the other girl?

[Post-Chorus]
Who's gonna put on the red dress
Scarlet letter on her chest
Can't love with this on her conscience
Tell me, who's the other girl?
Who's the other girl?

[Verse 2]
Oh, are you the one he's talkin' to
When he gets up and leaves the room
And comes back with a distance in his eyes?
Maybe I should be the one to leave
But damn, when he starts lovin' me
It makes me think I'm all that's on his mind, ah, ah

[Chorus]
Is it me? Is it you?
Tell me who, who's the other girl?
Who's the first? Who's the fool?
Who's the diamond? Who's the pearl?
Are you mad? Me too
And I wonder, in his world
Is it me? Is it you?
Who's the other girl?

[Post-Chorus]
Who's gonna put on the red dress
Scarlet letter on her chest
Can't love with this on her conscience
Tell me, who's the other girl?
Who's the other girl?
Oh, yeah

[Bridge]
I bet you're cool, I bet that's why you seem to occupy his time
I bet by now, you know about me

[Chorus]
Is it me? Is it you?
Tell me who, who's the other girl?
Who's the first? Who's the fool?
Who's the diamond? Who's the pearl?
Are you mad? Me too
And I wonder, in his world
Is it me? Is it you?
Oh, who's the other girl?

[Post-Chorus]
Who's gonna put on the red dress
Scarlet letter on her chest
Can't love with this on her conscience
Tell me, who's the other girl?
Oh, who's the other girl? Mmm
Who's the other girl?