“Find My Way” is one of the more densely-textured tracks on McCartney III, featuring two bass tracks, switching between a Moog bass and Paul’s famous Hofner, and two drum tracks, as well as several intertwining electric guitar parts. Engineer Steve Orchard spoke of how the song was recorded:

For Find My Way we used a quarter-inch Brenell tape machine. It’s got a speaker built into it, Paul will record a lick into it, and then we’ll play it back at different speeds through the speaker. We’ve got a tape loop set up with a tape reel the lid of a coffee can so you get a continuous loop. It’s got a sound-on-sound mode where it lifts the tape away from the record head so you can have a couple of different sounds playing at the same time. Then when you put it into playback mode you can play it at different speeds and get different octaves. We’ll record that into Pro Tools and edit them up.

The lyrics talk about offering someone emotional support in the worrying COVID-19 era. Sheet music for the melody appeared on a wall in Los Angeles on 5 December, 2020, as the second part of the #12DaysofPaul campaign.