I dropped a coin in a wishing well
I'd heard that's what you do
You drop a coin in a wishing well
To make your wishes come true

It must have been a real wishing well
What I wished for, I got
I wished for love in that wishing well
And now I wish I had not

Where's an un-wishing well?
I have to break the spell
Never again will I ever spend
A penny on any well

There has to be an un-wishing well
A magic to undo
All of the trouble I wished myself
The day that I wished for you
And oh, the trouble I wished myself
Not every wish should come true

There has to be an un-wishing well
There really has to be
All foolish wishes could be dispelled
And foolish lovers be free
Free of the spell of some wishing well
And free to love anew
Free to be careful of wishing wells
Not every wish should come true

Where's that un-wishing well?
I need to break this spell
Of pain and heartache and the mistake
Of falling in love too well

There has to be an un-wishing well
A magic to undo
All the trouble I wished myself
The day that I wished for you
And oh, the trouble I wished myself
Not every wish should come true

Show me the way and I'll gladly pay
To unwish unwise wishes far away