"Is It Love" by Mr. Mister explores the confusion and ambiguity surrounding a romantic relationship. The lyrics portray a situation where the protagonist expresses their love and affection for someone, but the other person responds with fear and uncertainty.

In the first verse, the protagonist confesses their love and holds the other person close, but receives a response that suggests their love is intimidating. This creates a sense of frustration and confusion for the protagonist, as their true feelings are not understood or reciprocated by the other person.

The chorus raises the central question of the song: "Is it love you're after?" The protagonist is uncertain about the other person's true intentions and desires. They long for clarity and honesty, wanting to know if the other person genuinely seeks love or if there are other hidden motives.

The second verse compares the situation to a broken record going round and round in circles without any resolution. It's a metaphorical representation of how their relationship seems to be stuck, with the same issues resurfacing repeatedly. The protagonist feels submerged and overwhelmed, while the other person hides their true emotions behind laughter.

Throughout the song, the protagonist seeks answers and longs for honesty. They want the other person to communicate their true feelings and intentions. The repeated question in the chorus reflects their yearning for transparency and a genuine connection.

Ultimately, "Is It Love" captures the frustration and uncertainty that can arise when one person is open and ready for love, while the other remains guarded or unsure. The song serves as a plea for truthfulness and a desire for an authentic and fulfilling relationship.