"I'm Not Okay (I Promise)" is a cover song originally performed by My Chemical Romance, but in this analysis, we'll focus on The Edge Of Reason's rendition. The song delves into themes of insecurity, inner turmoil, and the struggle to maintain a facade of happiness.

The lyrics in the verses depict a desire for honesty and a fear of disappointing others. The protagonist acknowledges their tendency to hide their true emotions, as they believe it's better to pretend everything is fine. The reference to breaking a foot from jumping out a window metaphorically represents the reckless behavior the protagonist might engage in as a means of escape.

The chorus, repeating the phrase "I'm not okay," serves as a declaration of the protagonist's emotional state. It expresses the exhaustion caused by trying to maintain a charade of happiness. "You wear me out" conveys how the pressure from others and the desire to please them is draining and overwhelming.

In the second verse, the protagonist addresses the people who fail to understand the depth of their struggles and dismiss their pain. They express frustration at being perceived as a joke, someone without substance or meaning. The line "Another line without a hook" suggests a lack of connection or relatability in their words, as if their true emotions and experiences aren't being understood or acknowledged.

The bridge confronts the individuals who dismissed the protagonist's struggles, urging them to forget about the judgment and invalidation they had previously faced. The protagonist declares that they are now "okay," but emphasizes that it's important for others to truly listen, as they are speaking their truth. The repetition of "trust me" in fragmented form highlights a plea for understanding and acceptance.

The final repetition of "I'm not okay" in the song's closing section reinforces the ongoing struggle the protagonist faces, emphasizing their unresolved emotional state.

Overall, "I'm Not Okay (I Promise)" delves into the complexities of mental and emotional struggles, exploring the conflict between wearing a mask of happiness and the desire for authentic understanding and acceptance. It reflects the need for open communication and empathy in order to foster genuine connections with others.