The song "All My Favorite Songs (Remix)" by Weezer featuring AJR explores themes of paradoxical emotions, self-reflection, and the struggle to understand oneself. The lyrics express a conflicted state of mind where the singer finds solace in slow and sad songs, while simultaneously feeling frustrated by the influence of certain people in their life. This duality is highlighted by the line "All my favorite people make me mad," suggesting that even though these individuals may cause frustration, they remain significant to the singer in some way.

The chorus further emphasizes the contradictory nature of the singer's experiences. They describe how everything that feels good is often perceived as bad, implying a sense of guilt or shame associated with enjoying certain aspects of life. This may reflect a longing for something different or a dissatisfaction with the singer's current circumstances.

In the verses, both Rivers Cuomo and Jack Met express vulnerabilities and desires. Cuomo admits to a love for parties but struggles with socializing, wanting to be rich but feeling guilty about it, and falling in love with those who dislike him. Met acknowledges being a "yes man," someone who constantly agrees with others in fear of facing his own identity. He expresses regret about not receiving calls and feeling ashamed, possibly alluding to a strained relationship with his parents.

Overall, the song delves into the complexity of human emotions and the internal conflicts individuals face. It touches upon the paradoxical nature of finding comfort in sad music, the frustrations caused by loved ones, and the struggle of self-acceptance. Through these introspective lyrics, Weezer and AJR capture the struggle of understanding oneself in a world of conflicting emotions and desires.